Address: 55 Dundas Street West, Toronto, Ontario, Canada M5G 2C3
Mailing Address: 350 Victoria Street, Toronto, Ontario, Canada M5B 2K3
Phone: 416-979-5000 | Fax: 416-979-5001
As the old saying goes, birds of a feather flock together, but according to a new study by researchers from Canada and China, birds -- or people in this case – also tend to cheat for others in the same social group without any personal gain.
“Cheating happens all the time, whether it’s intentional deceit or it’s perceived to be harmless,” says Fei Song, one of the study’s co-authors and a professor in organizational behaviour at Ted Rogers School of Business Management at Ryerson University. “People lie for a variety of reasons, but not only for themselves. Our study demonstrates that sometimes people cheat to help others with whom they have a connection at the expense of third parties who are more socially distant from the cheater.”
Song and her co-authors, Professor Bram Cadsby from the Department of Economics and Finance at the University of Guelph and Professor Ninghua Du of the College of Economics at the Shanghai University of Finance and Economics, conducted a series of tests to investigate their theory on social groups and cheating.
The researchers asked 900 students from two universities in China to participate in different scenarios of a simple money-allocation task. The students were divided into two main groups: allocators and recipients. The allocators were asked to divide 50 yuan ($10 CDN) between two students: one from the same university considered to be part of their same social group, and one from the other university who would be an “outsider”.
The allocators were told to either pick from a list of six options on how to split the money or choose the option based on a dice rolled privately. But there was a catch: none of the six options allowed the allocator to evenly split the 50 yuan between the two recipients.
The allocators who could select any option had the choice of giving either 0, 10, 20, 30, 40, or 50 yuan to the student from the same university with the rest going to the recipient from the other university.
When choosing freely, more than 70 per cent gave the student from their own university more money. However, they were only slightly generous with their money. Nearly two thirds of this group gave the student attending the same university 30 yuan with the rest of the money going to the student from the other university.
As for the allocators who chose the option based on their dice roll, the researchers found that 60 per cent of the students tended to cheat and choose options that would favour the recipient from the same university despite the number rolled on the dice. The average amount allocated to the student from their university was 28 yuan.
“Such cheating is likely widespread,” says Cadsby. “Students lend their homework to their classmates to copy, organization members lie about the bad behavior of their colleagues to protect them from punishment, skating judges conspire to award points that favour skaters from their own country and companies hire less qualified relatives of current employees. Our study examines students from very similar universities and backgrounds. Cheating for others might well be far more likely when one’s own group is in a competitive or hostile relationship with the other group. Loyalty will often trump abstract ethical principles, and a loyal cheater may even be hailed as a hero.”
The study, In-Group Favouritism and Moral Decision-Making, has been published online in the Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization and has been funded by the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada.
The full study can be found here.
Please note all three authors are currently in China. Professors Cadsby and Song are available for phone and Skype interviews.
About Ted Rogers School of Management at Ryerson University
Ted Rogers School of Management at Ryerson University is Canada’s leading entrepreneurial-focused business school shaping the country’s next generation of global leaders. Home to six schools of management, two Ryerson MBA programs, a Masters of Science in Management program and 14 cutting-edge research centres, institutes & labs, the faculty’s focus on academic rigor, combined with real-world experience, provides students with experiential learning and critical thinking skills needed to solve challenges facing today’s global economy. ryerson.ca/tedrogersschool
About University of Guelph
The University of Guelph is known for excellence in the arts and sciences, and for a commitment to developing exceptional thinkers and engaged citizens. U of G has nearly 28,000 undergraduate and graduate students at our campuses in Guelph, Toronto and Ridgetown and more than 122,000 alumni living in 150 countries. Students, faculty and staff pursue active inquiry and exercise creativity across a range of disciplines -- physical and life sciences, arts and humanities, social sciences, business, agricultural and veterinary sciences.
- 30 -